How Good Are the Mage Hero Talent Tier Sets in The War Within Season 3?

Posted 2025/07/01 at 4:21 PM by Wowhead

Our Guide Writers have detailed the remaining issues and provided Wishlists for their specs for the remainder of the Midnight development cycle. Explore all our released Wishlist editorials below.
Class Wishlists for Midnight

Death Knight Wishlist
Demon Hunter Wishlist
Druid Wishlist
Evoker Wishlist
Hunter Wishlist
Mage Wishlist
Monk Wishlist

Paladin Wishlist
Priest Wishlist
Rogue Wishlist
Shaman Wishlist

Warlock Wishlist
Warrior Wishlist
For a cursory breakdown of the changes coming to each specialization in Midnight, check out our Midnight Class Survival Guide.

Midnight Class Survival Guide

First Impressions of the War Within Season 3 Tier Set BonusesMage Tier Set Appearances for War Within Season 3Augur's Ephemeral PlumageRaid FinderNormalHeroicMythicArcane Mage Season 3 Tier Set Bonuses First Impressions

Spellslinger
Spellslinger Season 3 Tier Set Bonuses

Mage Spellslinger 11.2 Class Set 2pc - Arcane Blast damage increased by 20%. Direct Splinter damage has a 100% chance to grant a stack of Arcane Salvo.
Mage Spellslinger 11.2 Class Set 4pc - Splinter damage is increased 8%. Arcane Orb has a 100% chance to grant a stack of Arcane Salvo, up to 8 times. Upon reaching maximum stacks of Arcane Salvo, gain Intuition.

Implementation & Gameplay
Direct Splinter damage basically means anytime an Arcane Splinter hits a target as well as hits in this case. With the recent update, you can really feel this set's impact. One oddity here is that whenever you get to 20 stacks of Arcane Salvo using Arcane Missiles, it will not proc Intuition until you generate 1 more stack, over the 20 cap. This only happens with Arcane Missiles generated Arcane Salvo stacks. Another additional problem is that the set only works if you talent into Arcane Salvo in the spec talent tree preventing the set from opening up some options for talent choices which seems to be a bug, but it's hard to take anything as it will be instead of how it is, hopefully it is fixed. Otherwise this set works as described by the tooltip.

In AOE, this feels very good as you have a very low cooldown on Arcane Orb for when Orb Barrage fails to proc, in cooldowns you'll have very high uptime on Intuition. However in single target I suspect the loss of Jackpot! and the changes to Spellfrost Teachings will make Spellslinger a fair bit less interesting, this set does nothing to really alleviate these losses and the very passive nature of the set in single target will likely be something you don't really get much out of.

Strength & Content
This will change the strengths and weaknesses for Spellslinger a fair bit, in conjunction with the other changes made in this patch I think we'll see an increase in uncapped AOE dps paired with a subsequent decrease in single target (when in mythic+ talents) and priority dps relative to how Arcane measures up currently. There is a good chance that there are some talent shakeups for Spellslinger, I will wait for sims to declare anything, but I have creeping suspicion that Arcane Missiles related talents will take a hit with the 11.2 update to the hero spec.

Feedback
You rarely see the Intuition effect from the 4pc in single target and it is basically just %dmg mods on spells we already want to cast. This set had an opportunity to make dead Spellslinger talents like Shifting Shards or Unerring Proficiency have a season in the sun. This is especially true since both Frost and Arcane Mage both ignore these talents and have since each of them became choices which would present a real theme for the set.

Overall, I like the set, after the recent buff it works very well in AOE, however I am very disappointed with single target problem of the set which is just to buff Arcane Blast and Arcane Splinter. There are a few ways this could be resolved, spending Nether Precision could apply stacks of Arcane Salvo, or Arcane Missiles could apply twice as many stacks, either way, Intuition procs need to happen more in single target, since that is the part of this set that you actually feel in gameplay.

Sunfury
Sunfury Season 3 Tier Set Bonuses

Mage Sunfury 11.2 Class Set 2pc - Spellfire Spheres spell damage bonus is increased by 2%. Mana Cascade now grants an additional 0.5% Haste per stack.
Mage Sunfury 11.2 Class Set 4pc - Exceptional spells cast by your Phoenix adds an additional 1.0 sec to the duration of your next Arcane Soul. When your Phoenix expires, it empowers you even further beyond, granting Lesser Time Warp (the tooltip is weird, it should say 15% haste for 10 sec) and 10% increased spell damage for 13 sec.

Implementation & Gameplay
Part of this works in an ideal way, with the buff to Spellfire Spheres also applying to Lingering Embers, however the Mana Cascade buff currently does nothing (this is fixed now). The extra Haste, spell damage, and Arcane Soul duration after our cooldowns are over works as described, historically damage outside of cooldowns doesn't do much for our bottom line.

The Sunfury set won't really change anything extra a slightly faster pacing on average. The extra Arcane Soul time and buffs after our cooldowns run out is a really poor choice for us. Don't get me wrong, extra time in Arcane Soul is super fun, but the rotation is already tight enough timing wise for when you can Shifting Power before Touch of the Magi comes back up. The saving grace for Sunfury is that the gameplay at a baseline is still intact and feels good already.

Strength & Content
The set will be strong in virtually all content, especially if they fix the bug with Mana Cascade (this is fixed now). I do worry about the length of the burst window having gotten larger and larger over time, how much that will really matter though will vary from encounter to encounter. Overall, if tuning holds as is, we'll be playing a lot of Sunfury in 11.2! This set has no real weakness or strength and overall Arcane Mage is Arcane Mage regardless of hero talent choice.

Feedback
I do not understand why the final tier set should lack any real interactivity. Dragging out our cooldown window is the antithesis of fun and is constantly threatened for whether or not you can maximize value and doing it through mostly boring passive effects is kind of lame. If you're not going to go for interesting, you should go for exciting; make it so we spawn phoenixes frequently, make Ignite the Future lower the blast/barrage requirement for sphere generation, make it so Glorious Incandescence gives us 20x stacks of Arcane Salvo, or make Savor the Moment give Fire and Arcane Mage's each other's cooldowns when we use our own! Embrace rule of cool or make something that actually impacts rotations in a new interesting way, but this set isn't it. I think you should go back to formula with this one.

Spellslinger vs. Sunfury
As far as set interactions go, Spellslinger is the clear winner here, the set actually does interact with Arcane Orb in a way that makes you feel like you're rewarded for playing the spec correctly and comes off inspired. Sunfury by contrast just does things, you don't have to play well, they're not things you'll really notice much or interact with, the number will go up and that's all you're really getting from this set.

As far as effectiveness, I think the Sunfury and Spellslinger both are fairly in the same boat with each set being pretty good in power level, with the only exception being Spellslinger in single target. Current tuning, specifically due to the change of Spellfrost Teachings probably will favor Sunfury overall, however I am content to wait for simulation craft implementations and final tunings for answers to power level questions.

Finally, I want to express my hope that something is done to make the Sunfury tier actually worth thinking about in a meaningful way or rule of cool it and Spellslinger more interactive outside of AOE.

Fire Mage Season 3 Tier Set Bonuses First Impressions

Frostfire
Frostfire Season 3 Tier Set Bonuses

Mage Frostfire 11.2 Class Set 2pc - Comet Storm (via Isothermic Core), Frostfire Bolt, and Frostfire Burst (via Excess Fire) are buffed by 10% and can now contribute to Mastery: Ignite at 150% effectiveness.
Mage Frostfire 11.2 Class Set 4pc - Pyroblast now has a 20% chance to proc a Glacial Spike that also contributes to Mastery: Ignite.

Implementation & Gameplay
Now this is an exciting tier set! The idea with the 2p is that some of those frosty spells you have been casting now benefit from Mastery: Ignite. That alone is hype, but they are also slightly buffed and Mastery: Ignite at 150% effectiveness! The 4p makes Pyroblast much stronger, since it now has a chance to follow up with a Glacial Spike that also contributes to Mastery: Ignite. Stat weights are fluid, but Frostfire generally prefers Versatility currently since much of our damage didn't scale with Mastery: Ignite. This tier bonus makes Critical Strike and Mastery more valuable, and seems to promote gameplay that focuses on Mastery: Ignite spread in AoE. This is further exemplified by the fact that the bonus does not affect Flamestrike, meaning that there is now far more value to play Frostfire as the ignite spreader it has always dreamt of being. The big question is: Will it be enough?

It's hard to know all of the ways this tier bonus will shake things up for Frostfire, but the clear incentive is to cast as many Pyroblast as possible. Unfortunately, talents like Pyromaniac and Hyperthermia are likely out of reach due to the 2 point cost of Fevered Incantation and Fire's Ire. Picking these up while keeping Firefall and Meteor would lead to some extremely cursed pathing. I expect talents will stay the same for now, but if either of these 2 pointers are changed our options will swing open.

Aside from shaking up our stat weights, this tier also has the potential of slightly skewing our gameplay to favor more of our cool spell procs, or pooling them for Combustion. We will have to wait for sims to know the full impact.

Strength & Content
We don't have sims yet, and this set is very likely to change in some small ways. The value is hard to pin down since it depends on your Critical Strike and Mastery. When it comes to the 2p bonus:

Comet Storm contributes about 10% of our damage.
Frostfire Bolt contributes about 14% of our damage.
Frostfire Burst contributes about 3.5% of our damage.

All of these values are gaining 10% damage. Frostfire Bolt gains 50% Mastery: Ignite effectiveness; this and the damage increase should gain us around 3.5%. Comet Storm and Frostfire Burst do not currently contribute to Mastery: Ignite, so adding the damage bonus and ignite should increase damage by about 5.8-7% depending on Mastery. With the 4p, Glacial Spike typically adds around 7-10% based on procs, with 100% Mastery: Ignite effectiveness. Let's assume this adds around 2% on top.

Putting it all together brings our tier set estimation to 18-20%. Since this bonus heavily leans into Mastery: Ignite cleave, it does have to contend with Flamestrike. Since Flamestrike is already used at higher target counts for Frostfire (compared to Sunfury), I think this is a perfect fit for the hero talent. I'm not sure if I am convinced that this will make Frostfire ignite cleave viable in Mythic+, but I certainly hope we end up there!

Feedback
This set bonus is very exciting, and I think Blizzard has done well to deliver a passive damage increase in such an exciting way. My only gripe with it is the animation of Glacial Spike. When you proc the Glacial Spike you skip over the casting animation and lob it at the target with extreme speed. The spell is only on the screen for only a split second, so it is easy to miss. I think this is a missed opportunity for a spell with such a cool animation. I would like to see some of the casting animation added, so that it is clear to the player and others around them when it procs.

Visuals of Glacial Spike. The left is the proc for Frostfire, the right is the animation for Frost.

Sunfury
Sunfury Season 3 Tier Set Bonuses

Mage Sunfury 11.2 Class Set 2pc - Spellfire Sphere damage bonus is now 3% per sphere. Mana Cascade effect is doubled.
Mage Sunfury 11.2 Class Set 4pc - Gain 10% increased damage and Lesser Time Warp for 13 seconds after Combustion. Hyperthermia from Memory of Al'ar extended by 1 second per exceptional spell cast by the Arcane Phoenix.

Implementation & Gameplay
The 2p part of this tier is some passive damage and haste. We get three times as much value from Spellfire Sphere and double value from Mana Cascade. Spellfire Sphere is a buff that we have at 5 stacks for most of the time we are in combat. Mana Cascade stacks 10 times (or 15 with Ignite the Future) but fluctuates a lot in combat. This buff quickly caps out during Combustion if played properly. The 4p provides more haste with Lesser Time Warp and damage for Hyperthermia, which happens after Combustion ends. It also extends our Hyperthermia window substantially.

The biggest thing you will notice with this tier set is that Hyperthermia feels ridiculously long. Typically, your Arcane Phoenix will cast 5 exceptional spells in Combustion. This translates to 12 seconds of Hyperthermia (or more with Ignite the Future) following each Combustion. Hyperthermia has been redesigned now to increase the damage of your Flamestrike and Pyroblast over the duration.

Swapping out the previous tier set (Jewels of the Aspectral Emissary) should only account for a minor increase of the cooldown between Combustions in Single Target, but the total time between in the "filler rotation" should remain mostly the same thanks to the combination of longer Hyperthermias and added haste. The difference will be more noticeable in cleave and AoE, since Glorious Incandescence pushes the cooldown lower on average in these scenarios (due to the combination of Unleashed Inferno and Kindling proccing 3 times with Fire Blast).

Strength & Content
All of these bonuses are passive and aren't specific to Single Target or AoE. This tier set should moderately boost our damage across the board.

We don't have sims yet, and this set is very likely to change in some small ways. When it comes to the 2p bonus, we spend most of our time at 5 Spellfire Spheres. This portion of the 2p should represent an increase of around 9.82%. Haste from Mana Cascade should increase our damage by about 5.5%. These combined should put the value of the 2p around 15-16%.

The 4p bonus is a bit harder to gauge. The buffs provide 10% damage and 15% haste with an uptime of around 25-30%, but never during our Combustion. Hyperthermia uptime is also substantially increased. Based on some spell overrides and napkin math, I'm expecting the Hyperthermia part to be around 4.4% and the buffs portion to come in around 6%. In total, that brings us to a 25-26% increase. Keep in mind that there are many other interactions between these buffs that I have not fully accounted for.

When it comes to content, this tier bonus can be very frustrating to play in Mythic+. Unreasonably long Hyperthermia windows following Combustion make our cooldown window very long, which either leads to wasting Hyperthermia or holding Combustion to avoid waste. Even worse, we now suffer from chronic "Spymaster's Web Syndrome". What I mean by this is that if you ever die in combat and get resurrected, you lose all of your Spellfire Spheres effectively disabling your tier bonus for about a minute. Fire is already overly punishing when mistakes occur, and these two points make it even worse.

Feedback
Sunfury is in a really bad spot when it comes to Single Target currently. This is more of an issue with Sunfury as a hero talent for Fire, so I'm not sure if we can expect the tier bonus to address it too much. This tier set may be strong, but it may not fully bridge the gap in a raid. Sunfury Fire has relatively low burst, and many boss mechanics on the final encounters have huge damage amps (King's Hunger & Destabilized for example).

Damage aside, the issue I have with this tier is that it focuses on Hyperthermia. As much as I love Sunfury mobility, I'm not sure passive percentage increases and mashing Pyroblast longer makes for an interesting tier set. This bluepost is from patch 11.1:

Developers' notes: Fire’s resource economy post-The War Within has been too generous, which has made certain spells like Fireball and Scorch feel unnecessary while also impacting how we can tune Pyroblast and Flamestrike. Our goal here is to reduce access to Phoenix Flames and less-so Fire Blast while amping up your spenders to help increase skill expression, increase your reliance on casting, and make exciting spells hit a bit harder.

FlamestrikePyroblastHyperthermiaImproved ScorchJewels of the Aspectral EmissaryTime AnomalyPyroblastFrost Mage Season 3 Tier Set Bonuses First Impressions

Frostfire
Frostfire Season 3 Tier Set Bonuses

Mage Frostfire 11.2 Class Set 2pc - Meteor, Frostfire Burst, and Frostfire Bolt deal 10% more damage and now apply Ignite, dealing an additional 30% damage over 9 sec
Mage Frostfire 11.2 Class Set 4pc - Casting Glacial Spike has a 100% chance to also cast a Pyroblast, dealing (705% of Spell power) Fire damage. Additionally, Pyroblast now benefits from Ignite.

Implementation & Gameplay
Thematically, this set bonus is extremely good. Mastery: Ignite is one of the most thematic Fire Mage spells, and this set bonus brings that to Frost. Additionally, Glacial Spike is a strong talent that sees a very high rate of usage, but it has a purely Frost theme. By adding this powerful Pyroblast to every Glacial Spike cast, it makes the talent fit nicely into the Frostfire theme. It does make Glacial Spike a mandatory talent, but it has been that way for some time now already and outside of a major Frost Mage rework that is unlikely to change. In terms of gameplay, with an ideal implementation this shouldn't massively alter the rotation except that because the Pyroblast determines whether it will critically strike on cast, the somewhat standard Glacial Spike > Flurry combo will see reduced value (Glacial Spike determines whether it will critically strike when it hits the target). There are some potential rotational problems due to a lack of Ice Lance bonuses here and due to problematic critical strike and mastery scaling, but they should be straightforward to fix during the PTR cycle if they do prove to be problematic.

Strength & Content
This set bonus is definitely geared more towards single target damage, since so much of Frost's damage in AoE comes from Blizzard and Frozen Orb. This isn't necessarily a bad thing, since priority target damage is typically quite important throughout all types of content, but it would be nice to see some more AoE bonuses. Blizzard has already majorly tuned the Pyroblast effect in the second build of the PTR, so it would not be surprising to see further tweaks to address this.

Feedback
While I generally really like this set bonus and think focusing it on Frostfire was an excellent idea, there are some potential issues that may need fixes if they do prove problematic.

Because Frostfire Bolt gains power from this set while Ice Lance does not, it removes incentive from casting Ice Lance. There is a chance that this could end up resulting in a meta rotation that starts to ignore casting Ice Lance in some cases. To help avoid this, it would be a good idea for the set to also give some bonus to Ice Lance.
Currently, the damage stored in the Ignite appears to be calculated such that it ignores the bonus damage from critical strikes. This could result in problems where Frostfire Frost Mages want less critical strike on their gear.
Since the bonuses are looking a little weak in AoE situations, it might be a good idea to add something extra to set to either passively spread these Ignites from the primary target (making it feel even more like Fire Mage) or to add some extra AoE Fire damage when using rotational spells like Blizzard and Frozen Orb.
Some of the damage from this set does not scale with Mastery: Icicles. This is already a huge problem for Frostfire where the stat is extremely undesirable because of no mastery scaling on effects like Frostfire Burst, Frostfire Infusion, and Meteor. With the new set bonus, this problem is only going to get worse.

Spellslinger
Spellslinger Season 3 Tier Set Bonuses

Mage Spellslinger 11.2 Class Set 2pc - Ice Lance and Icicle damage increased by 20%. Direct Splinter damage has a 25% chance to grant a stack of Cold Front.
Mage Spellslinger 11.2 Class Set 4pc - When Frozen Orb deals damage to one or more enemies, it has a 15% chance to grant a stack of Cold Front. When Cold Front summons a Frozen Orb, increase your spell damage by 10% for 10 sec.

Implementation & Gameplay
A big part of Spellslinger has been the extra Frozen Orb casts it provides, so it's not too out of place to empower the Cold Front talent to help the Mage continue to produce more Frozen Orbs. However, this makes the Cold Front talent mandatory (the set currently does not provide stacks of Cold Front if you don't have the talent). While it's not unusual for set bonuses to encourage or require certain talents, Cold Front isn't really a beloved talent that a lot of Frost Mages are hoping to play with. Rotationally, it's hard to say whether there will be any significant impact from this set.

Strength & Content
Right now, this set bonus looks a little weak on the surface, but it's hard to be certain until we have simulations available to precisely evaluate its strength. The main concern I have for the strength of this set bonus is the inconsistency of Cold Front itself. Because you have to aim the Frozen Orb procs and the Frozen Orbs themselves don't follow your targets around, it is very common to miss a lot of ticks against raid bosses that need to be moved or in delves and dungeons when groups of targets do not stay still or are not perfectly stacked. Tying some of the Cold Front stack generation to Frozen Orb ticks actually hitting enemies provides further punishment in these cases when nothing is in range of it when it already makes the talent inconsistent on its own.

Feedback
Overall, I find this Spellslinger set bonus to be underwhelming. Focusing the bonuses this season on hero talents was a good idea, but this one could use some major changes.

The biggest problem I have this set bonus is its focus Cold Front. If this is going to stay, I'd like to see adjustments to Cold Front itself, such as not having to aim the Frozen Orb or just having it trigger it a different spell like Comet Storm or some simple damage effect to make selecting this talent not feel as frustrating.
Because Cold Front encourages casting Frostbolt over Ice Lance and now there is an extra feedback loop of extra Cold Front stacks from Frozen Orb itself, there is danger that this could discourage using Ice Lance as much as it is intended to be used in the rotation.

Frostfire vs. Spellslinger
Frostfire is the clear winner over Spellslinger here. Mastery: Ignite is among the most iconic parts of a Fire Mage, so having that as part of a Frost Mage's tooltip really plays into the fantasy. On top of that, the set bonuses generally just fit into the current playstyle of Frostfire Frost Mage without requiring any unpopular talent choices. The biggest problem for Spellslinger is the focus on Cold Front. While having another source of Cold Front stacks that doesn't come directly from casting Frostbolt is nice, this talent is generally not very fun to play with. Having to aim where you want the Frozen Orb to go is annoying and Frozen Orb itself often has trouble hitting all of its ticks on your enemies even when it is aimed perfectly. If this Spellslinger bonus stays as it is, I would be disappointed if Spellslinger ends up stronger when 11.2.0 releases, as I would not be excited to play with it.

Comment by TaurnokLosing the current Arcane 2-4pc set is really going to suck... These seem underwhelming in comparison.Comment by JerkntI really wish Spellslinger WILL be better for Frost because I don't enjoy Frostfire as much as other people. While ignite sounds nice, it's not for me.Comment by TyneicI really wish Spellslinger WILL be better for Frost because I don't enjoy Frostfire as much as other people. While ignite sounds nice, it's not for me.Comment by GnomesRuleare we seriously not gonna talk about how hot fire mages are?Comment by AquaImperiumi dont care what the numbers say for Frost Frostfire, as long as they keep the thematic on point then i'll continue to LOVE it every day.Comment by CentiasFrostfire Frost bonuses should include Ice Lance and Frozen Orb getting Ignite damage, and in some way the Ingite damage or the damage of Fire spells should scale with Mastery, whether through the tier set or through the hero talents.

I'm curious whether the Frostfire 4p specifically is stronger for Frost or Fire. I would guess Fire getting random Glacial Spikes with Pyroblast is probably a lot more significant than Frost getting Pyroblasts with every Glacial Spike, because typically about 5x more Pyroblasts get cast in a single target fight than Glacial Spikes, and Fire actually gets mastery scaling on the Glacial Spike, whereas Frost doesn't get Mastery scaling on the Pyroblast. It also looks like it doesn't even benefit from Shatter (though it should benefit from but NOT consume Winter's Chill, and/or get its chance to crit from the Glacial Spike that triggered it).