Este sitio hace uso intenso de JavaScript.
Por favor habilita JavaScript en tu navegador.
Tema Clásico
Tema Thottbot
No More Lies and a Choice - What's Going On With Sylvanas? We Take A Closer Look
Moderna
Publicado
19/02/2021 a las 02:54
por
DiscordianKitty
Lady Sylvanas Windrunner is one of the most popular and controversial characters in World of Warcraft's history. People seem to both love her and hate her with an equal amount of passion. Throughout Battle for Azeroth, we saw this play out in-game, as certain Horde questlines were split between Sylvanas loyalists and Saurfang loyalists. By the end of BfA, all ambiguity seemed to be gone, as Sylvanas had fully transformed from the morally grey character she might have been once (depending who you ask) to the straight-up villain she became by the start of Shadowlands. But what is the future for Sylvanas? Is she destined to become a raid boss, like Gul'dan or Arthas? Or is there still hope for the Banshee Queen? Will we see Sylvanas's redemption?
Warning: Spoilers from the BlizzConline leaks ahead.
In a recent interview with
Lead Narrative Designer Steve Danuser
, we asked this exact question. The reply was, essentially, that it's not that simple, but that we would at least learn more about her motivations.
I don't think it's as simple as saying will she or won't she be redeemed? I think we will learn more things about her, and a lot of people might change their point of view on some of how they see her. Some people won't, because they've already decided what they think, or what they want to be true, but our job as storytellers is to continue to evolve these characters and show new sides of them - and that's something I'm very pleased with what we're doing in Shadowlands. So it'll definitely give fans of Syvanas is more things to think about, and that was one of the goals we set out to do.
Throughout Battle for Azeroth, and even before in Legion, Sylvanas's motivations were shrouded in mystery. We've only recently learned that she has been allied with the Jailer ever since before Cataclysm. However, Danuser's prediction that we would learn more has at least come true.
Over the last few weeks, as the
Story of Torghast
gradually unlocked, players have unlocked certain cinematics featuring Sylvanas, the Jailer, and their prisoner, Anduin Wrynn.
Read More about the Story of Torghast Here
We have seen that Sylvanas and the Jailer have been planning to forge Anduin into some sort of weapon - and that Sylvanas, at least, hoped to convince Anduin to choose to join their side, rather than use brute force on him. Instead, she debates him, and we get our first glimpse of those motivations Danuser promised. Sylvanas claims that nothing in the universe is fair - not life, not death - and that she and the Jailer intend to rip it all down. She even tries to appeal to Anduin's sense of justice.
Sylvanas: No more secrets. No more lies. You are a weapon we will use to achieve our ends.
Anduin: I will not become an instrument of death.
Sylvanas: So you favor...life, is that it? That momentary flicker. Every cruel second spent delaying the inevitable in an endless war that you, like every Wrynn before you, will not survive.
Sylvanas: You know the truth. Nothing is fair. Not life, not death.
Sylvanas: So we're going to tear it all down.
Anduin: And what purpose will that serve? Everyone suffers, Sylvanas. But destroying everything will not take away the pain.
Sylvanas: Ah, you misunderstand. We're breaking a system that has always been flawed, and remaking it into one that is just.
Anduin: Do you expect me to believe that, after all this time, you've been fighting for justice?
Sylvanas: How can I convince you? From our first breath to our last, every decision is made for us. Then the afterlife decides what eternity we must endure. We can't even choose who we... We couldn't control anything. But through the Jailer, control of our fate will at last be possible.
Anduin: Look around you! At what, and who you've joined. What makes you believe you're not just a weapon to achieve his ends?
Sylvanas: You have a choice to consider. Join us willingly...or be made to serve.
Anduin: I thought you believed in free will, Sylvanas.
Sylvanas: We've never had free will, Little Lion. But that...is about to change.
Despite her efforts, Sylvanas is not successful. In a final cutscene, unlocked only by players who have both completed the
Torghast
storyline and have killed Sire Denathrius in the Castle Nathria raid, the Jailer appears to have lost his patience with Sylvanas as he informs her it's time for Anduin to become their weapon, whether she thinks he's ready or not. She approaches Anduin again, and this time the conversation takes a turn that shows a side of Sylvanas we really haven't seen for years.
As Anduin wonders why Sylvanas keeps telling him he has a choice - when it's clear he will be forced either way - he suddenly decides it's because there's a small shred of mortality left in her. He uses this to turn the debate around on her, and suddenly we see chinks in Sylvanas's machiavellian armor. She shows vulnerability - even doubt - and before the scene ends, we see Anduin has completely turned the tables on Sylvanas. He is the one asking her to make a choice, and we are left wondering what she will decide.
Sylvanas: Sire Denathrius has been taken prisoner. What is our plan to recover him?
Jailer: Every soul has its purpose. Denathrius has fulfilled his.
Jailer: We must forge our next weapon.
Sylvanas: He is not ready.
Jailer: Then a more direct approach is necessary. We have not come this far for you to falter now. You know what must be done.
--
Anduin: Ah... there she is again. You know, these endless lectures of yours...
Sylvanas: ... have failed to convince you. Regardless, the conversation is over. One way or another, we will have you.
Sylvanas: So I will offer this... one last time. Join our cause, or be made to serve.
Anduin: What kind of choice is that? Why even give me...
Anduin: ... It's the choice you never had. Despite all your grand designs, there's still some shred of your mortality haunting you. As if the Banshee Queen hasn't entirely eclipsed the Ranger-General.
Sylvanas: Don't.
Anduin: Now I understand why you brought me here. Why you tried so hard to persuade me. Because if you can get me to let go of hope, you finally can too.
Sylvanas: Enough!
Sylvanas: Submit! You are only making this harder on yourself.
Anduin: Not harder on me... right now, you, with all the power... how would you use it?
Sylvanas: I've not come this far to falter now.
Anduin: Then why do you hesitate?
Anduin: Make your choice, Sylvanas Windrunner.
As it stands, Sylvanas's story, and the possibility of a redemption arc, has paused on a cliffhanger.
From the Blizzconline leaks
, we know we will "come face-to-face with the Banshee Queen herself in a fateful confrontation" in the upcoming Sanctum of Domination raid. A tantalizing description.
So what can we draw from this? Can Anduin genuinely see a shred of mortality left in Sylvanas, or is he just fooling himself? Does she truly believe she's working to the greater good? And even if she does, can that ever justify the actions she's taken to get to this point?
That Shred of Mortality
Throughout Sylvanas's history, there are hints at that same mortality Anduin saw. She has a vulnerable side that shows a capacity for love, particularly when it involves her own family - her sisters. However, she also almost always seems to actively try to deny and suppress this part of herself.
One classic example is the Burning Crusade quest
Viaje a Entrañas
, offered to players after they discover
El collar de Sylvanas
in Sylvanas's ancestral home - Windrunner Spire.
This necklace is actually one of three. In the novel
Beyond the Dark Portal
, Sylvanas's sister, Alleria Windrunner, had three nearly identical necklaces made - one for each of the Windrunner sisters. She sent the sapphire one to Sylvanas, the ruby one to their other sister, Vareesa, and kept the emerald one for herself. It was her final gift to her sisters before leaving through the Dark Portal during the events of Warcraft II - and she wouldn't be seen or heard from again until Legion.
Bringing the necklace to Sylvanas causes her to show a hint of genuine emotion, as she clearly still feels something for her sisters, but she composes herself quickly and claims her past life, and those she might once have loved, means nothing to her.
<Sylvanas takes the necklace from your grasp.>
It can't be! After all this time, I thought it was lost forever.
<After a lingering moment the Lady seems to become aware once again of her surroundings, composing herself.>
You thought this would amuse me? Do you think I long for a time before I was the queen of the Forsaken? Like you, it means nothing to me, and Alleria Windrunner is a long dead memory!
<She drops the amulet to the ground.>
You may now remove yourself from my presence, <class>.
Afterwards, she sings
Lament of the Highborn
- a beautiful moment that makes this quest a favorite for many to this day. The implication is that the necklace has had a deeply emotional impact on her, despite what she claims.
Later interactions with her sisters carry similar themes. In the novel
War Crimes
, which is set between the events of the Siege of Orgrimmar and Warlords of Draenor, Sylvanas finds herself opening up to the possibility of a relationship with Vareesa when they find common ground in their hatred for the fallen Warchief Garrosh and conspire to have him assassinated. Vareesa ultimately backs out of their plan, and Sylvanas seems to feel genuine hurt and betrayal as her ideas of a future with her sister seem no longer possible to her.
Later, in the pre-Battle for Azeroth comic
Windrunner; Three Sisters
, Sylvanas seems to have organized to have Vareesa and Alleria assassinated - but she stops the assassination after Vareesa acknowledges the betrayal and apologizes to her.
Granted, these are very, very, very small hints of mortality inside her (not actively assassinating her sisters is a very low bar for moral goodness) but the hints have still consistently been there, throughout Sylvanas's history.
(It's worth noting that Sylvanas's sisters aren't her only siblings - she had a younger brother, Lirath, who was killed by Orcs during the second war. One can't help wondering whether he might still be found in the Shadowlands.)
But even if there is a shred of something redeemable inside of Sylvanas, can it be enough?
Sylvanas's Relationship with Death
Sylvanas has, by this point, committed many atrocities, and has been the cause of countless deaths. She claims this is all for some greater good. Before we examine that, it's worth taking a look at her own relationship with death.
Death in World of Warcraft is, quite literally, only the beginning. Azeroth has been populated with undead characters for many years, and now, Shadowlands is populated with dead characters. People who have been dead in Azeroth since Classic, like Mankrik's wife, can be found merrily enjoying their afterlives. Sylvanas exists in a universe where death isn't even remotely final.
To Sylvanas, death is not a big deal, and is even sometimes necessary for a better future. And she's not just flippant about the death of her enemies. During War Crimes, when she planned to have a relationship with Vareesa, she quite cheerfully plotted Vareesa's death, reasoning that no living Elf could be happy in the Undercity. Ghoulish as that is, it also gives us a perspective into Sylvanas's views on death in general.
The fact is,
Sylvanas is dead.
She spent many years leading a race of people who had already died.
She has personally raised people unto undeath and watched them embrace their new existence.
She has, on at least one occasion, expressed the opinion that a loved one's existence would improve if they died and became undead.
She's travelled to the afterlife and knows what happens to people after they die.
She's moved to the afterlife and has developed a relationship with someone who rules a realm people go to after they die.
Perhaps it shouldn't be that surprising that she wouldn't take death as seriously as we might, especially now. For Sylvanas, death is just a milestone that almost everyone she knows has been through.
Not that this justifies her attitude towards death, it's merely an attempt to understand it.
Which brings us to the motivations behind all that Sylvanas has done.
The Greater Good
Sylvanas claims that she started the Fourth War, burned Teldrassil, and sent countless innocent souls to the Maw - a land of torture and pain - all for some greater good. As she said when she shattered the Helm of Domination,
"This world is a prison, and I will set us all free."
Are life, death, and all the rest really built around terrible injustices that she plans to rip down and set right? Could she see the death and torture of innocent souls as nothing more than a temporary unpleasant situation to get through as part of fighting this far greater injustice? Could that ever still justify genocide - even the fictional genocide of a fantasy race, many of whom have since been rescued from the Maw and are enjoying a pleasant afterlife in Ardenweald?
Well, No. But we don't believe Sylvanas really is working for the greater good any more than Anduin does. Only that she thinks she is.
Sylvanas and the Jailer
Everything that Sylvanas has done has all been part of the Jailer's plan. She seems to have unwavering faith in the Jailer. However, apart from the fact that he's an obvious bad guy, there are many signs that her trust is massively misplaced.
For a start, Sylvanas seems particularly upset about the lack of choice that she's had in her own fate, and convinced that the Jailer's plan will help set things right.
Sylvanas: You know the truth. Nothing is fair. Not life, not death.
Sylvanas: How can I convince you? From our first breath to our last, every decision is made for us. Then the afterlife decides what eternity we must endure. We can't even choose who we... We couldn't control anything. But through the Jailer, control of our fate will at last be possible.
Anduin: I thought you believed in free will, Sylvanas.
Sylvanas: We've never had free will, Little Lion. But that...is about to change.
However, she also seems unaware of the Jailer's link to the Frostmourne and the Helm of Domination, which turned Arthas into the Lich King in the first place. This lead directly to many of the things that have both defined Sylvanas and have caused her great suffering - the horrors of the Scourge, the attack on and slaughter of her people, her own death, being ripped away from a peaceful afterlife to suffer, undead, under Arthas's control, and her entire existence as the Banshee Queen of the Forsaken. Would she still follow the Jailer if she was aware of just how much he had to do with her fate - the same fate she seems so bitter about?
What's more, if we look at the opening dialogue from the Sylvanas's Choice cinematic, we can see instantly how Sylvanas's faith in the Jailer is misplaced.
Sylvanas: Sire Denathrius has been taken prisoner. What is our plan to recover him?
Jailer: Every soul has its purpose. Denathrius has fulfilled his.
Jailer: We must forge our next weapon.
Sylvanas: He is not ready.
Jailer: Then a more direct approach is necessary. We have not come this far for you to falter now. You know what must be done.
Sylvanas approaches the Jailer, expecting him to already have a plan to rescue Denathrius. She doesn't ask "Is there a plan to recover him", she asks "What is our plan to recover him". This shows how confident she is in the Jailer. She trusts so much that there will be a plan, she doesn't even waste time asking if there is one. It also shows how her trust is misplaced - while she assumes the Jailer must already have a plan, he doesn't seem to have even considered bothering to form one - and when his response indicates this, she is silent, as if momentarily taken aback. This moment must shake her confidence in him, even if it's just by a little. And if she can't even trust him to rescue an ally, then how can she trust him to set the world right?
As the cinematic progresses, we also see how Sylvanas seems to internalize the Jailer's words, and then repeat them as if they're her own, almost as if she's been brainwashed:
The Jailer to Sylvanas: Then a more direct approach is necessary.
We have not come this far for you to falter now.
You know what must be done.
Sylvanas to Anduin: I've not come this far to falter now.
It seems clear that Sylvanas's relationship with the Jailer is an unhealthy one, and that her trust in him is misplaced - that while he's convinced her that she's working for a greater good, this is ultimately a lie. It's also possible that a part of her knows this. She repeats the Jailer's words, "I've not come this far to falter now" almost like a comforting mantra, to dismiss her doubts. But the fact that she pauses when Anduin tells her to make her choice is evidence that those doubts are still there.
Sylvanas can probably never justify what she's done, but she can come to realize that she was manipulated and mislead, and regret her actions.
More importantly, she can also finally decide to stop trying to repress the part of her that feels genuine emotion, the part that makes her claim she doesn't need or want a relationship with her family anymore. Sylvanas had already met the Jailer when she was busy planning a future with Vareesa - almost as if she was ready to turn her back on the Jailer in favor of feeling like she had a family again. Her disappointment when she felt betrayed by Vareesa might even explain why, in the pre-Battle for Azeroth novel
Before the Storm
, she was so adamant that living and undead could never build relationships. Either way, it seemed to be the very last time she showed any interest in a future that didn't involve bringing about the Jailer's plan.
Having said that, if Sylvanas is to be redeemed, it would be a difficult journey. She has a long history of repressing the only good in her, she's committed some terrible atrocities, and she has some very warped views about love, relationships, and death. Even one of her most "shred of mortality" moments - wanting a relationship with her sister - involved a plan to kill her first. That's... pretty evil, no matter which way you look at it.
And while Anduin may be the one character that could possibly find redemption for even the evilest of the evil... The
Blizzconline leaks
including a "Chains of Domination Anduin" strongly suggests we will not be going into Patch 9.1 with Sylvanas ready to question the Jailer's orders. It will be interesting to see how the "fateful" confrontation we've been promised her will turn out.
Obtiene Wowhead
Premium
USD $2
Un mes
Disfruta de una experiencia libre de publicidad, desbloquea características premium y dale tu soporte al sitio!
Mostrar 0 comentarios
Ocultar 0 comentarios
Inicia sesión para publicar un comentario
Comentarios en Inglés (130)
Escribir un Comentario
No has iniciado sesión. Por favor
entra a tu cuenta
o
registra una cuenta
para añadir tu comentario.
Publicación anterior
Publicación siguiente