Did i really deserve to get guild kick?

Сообщение от Hyperspacerebel

I have read your posts. You are simply wrong.

Yet, you provide no evidence, no argument, nothing.

I very much doubt you even have an argument against what I've said.
There are no facts to cite, other than those listed in the OP's post. This is entirely a matter of one's opinion on the appropriate way to run a guild.

I've stated that I believe a guild can reasonbly demand that its members keep themselves open for guild runs. This is to ensure that the guild can actually play through content. A guild *cannot* reasonably demand that a guild member ask permission before accepting an invitation to run through content that the guild is not engaged in. A guild does not "own" its members, thus it does not have any justification in demanding that level of authority over their actions in-game.

In punishing a member for "getting saved" to content that the guild had no intent of running, they were behaving unfairly and irrationally. I have made this argument before, and I see no reason why I should have to type it again, merely to save you the trouble of going back and reading the thread.

A guild can do whatever it wants. Your'e not being forced to stay there.

Сообщение от Braevia

The question asked was whether the kick was deserved. As the rule was unreasonable, the answer is no.

Сообщение от Hyperspacerebel

As the rule was unreasonable

There you go again...no argument, no evidence.

Сообщение от 549991

This post was from a user who has deleted their account.

Сообщение от 423556

This post was from a user who has deleted their account.

Сообщение от 132362

This post was from a user who has deleted their account.

Сообщение от barthem

The question asked was whether the kick was deserved. As the rule was unreasonable, the answer is no.

He agreed to that rule when he joined the Guild. It's not as "unreasonable" as you're calling it out to be.

The rule was there when he joined. It wasn't made up on the spot just to justify kicking him. The rule encompassed all 10 mans; it did not exclude 10 mans the Guild didn't have scheduled. His situation did not deserve exemption from said rule.

If you joined a Guild with strict rules, expect those rules to be enforced. You are not special.

still, these werent strict rules, i dont know how many times guildmembers did VoA10 or naxx.
still they didnt get kicked.

Сообщение от Hyperspacerebel

still, these werent strict rules, i dont know how many times guildmembers did VoA10 or naxx.
still they didnt get kicked.

And you know for a fact that they didn't ask?

Сообщение от Davidson

still, these werent strict rules, i dont know how many times guildmembers did VoA10 or naxx.
still they didnt get kicked.

And you know for a fact that they didn't ask?

Let it go man, let it go..

Сообщение от Hyperspacerebel

Let it go man, let it go..

Let what go? I'm not the one who came here complaining that I got gkicked for not following the rules.

Сообщение от 423556

This post was from a user who has deleted their account.

Сообщение от Braevia

still, these werent strict rules, i dont know how many times guildmembers did VoA10 or naxx.
still they didnt get kicked.

And you know for a fact that they didn't ask?

You know for a fact that they did?

Сообщение от Braevia

As the rule was unreasonable

There you go again...no argument, no evidence.

You have no evidence of the rule being "reasonable", by that measure.

Сообщение от 150529

This post was from a user who has deleted their account.

Сообщение от Hyperspacerebel

You know for a fact that they did?

I don't need to know anything -- they are irrelevant to my argument. Your side is the one bringing them in, so you're the one who needs to prove it.

You have no evidence of the rule being "reasonable", by that measure.
I already gave it. You just keep refusing to read my posts.

Сообщение от Davidson

So I guess being a wowhead patron or whatever makes it so that you're not wrong. And if people disagree with you, you can just accuse them of not reading your posts.

Where can I sign up?

Сообщение от 517094

This post was from a user who has deleted their account.

Сообщение от 150529

This post was from a user who has deleted their account.

Сообщение от Braevia

Сообщение от Hyperspacerebel

No, you didn't. You're just stalling for time because you have no argument.

Pages 3 and 4 say you're wrong.

You're acting like a spoiled kid, who puts his hand over his ears so he can't here anything and therefore doesn't have to respond.

Did i really deserve to get guild kick?

Ответить