This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
I have to say when I started raiding with my hunter the biggest Epic loot I got was the Dragonstalker BP. Our guild had been doing BWL for a while and all the time we killed Nefarian the BP would never drop but eventually it did and I was the first hunter in our guild to get it and I had finally got my 8/8 for that set. Good times!
For me my most epic loot was simply a vendor item, on my first trip into dalaran i saw the First aid vendor and saw the antiseptic soaked wrappings, which needless to say as a RPer i just had to have after a long day of questing in northrend, during a guild meeting i had all the respect a seasoned adventurer deserved
Getting the Staff of Primal Fury off hex lord was big for me, since the tenticle staff from Illhoof seems to have eluded every druid in my guild, between both day and night crew doing runs each week, and always downing illhoof i dont believe it ever dropped for either.
My Transcendence Pants. Rags only dropped like three of those for my guild ever. $%^&*!@...
Muckbreath the baby crocolisk. nuff said.
Sinister squashling
My most epic loot ever was the tabard of flames from the WoW TCG. The first EPIC TABARD? Totally worth the box of cards I bought, even if it's totally ugly. I can't get enough epics :D
My most epic loot was The Horseman's Reins because it's just so awesome!
I had just hit lvl 60 an i was 200g short of my epic ground mount an so i started farming a Tiny Crimson Whelpling an about on my 3rd kill i got one HELLO 400g an i farmed another one an he is now my friend but that is my EPIX LOOT ;p
Most epic drop I ever got (on this toon) was the Tabard of the Explorer. It took countless zones and tons of time, but the scenery was well worth it.
I spent hours farming for an emerald whelp, I had all the others and I just wanted to complete my pet whelpling set. I must have spent two days 8 hours a day endlessly grinding them, but eventually it dropped :)