For at least 10 seconds I read the title as 'Aerosmith'.
I have the Arcanite Reaper plans on Whitemane. Hit me up! Name is Bruteas.
Came here cause i still cant decide what to choose and "you should pick honestly comes down to one thing: preference." doesn't help.
If you are not guild blacksmith - then you shouldn't pick any.
You might want to remove Bleakwood Hew, Darkspear, and Blood Talon from this list as they aren't available in Classic.
Not sure why Titanic Leggings wouldn't be able to drop even now as it's a random world drop, while Lionheart helm is the same and not mentioned?
So, I'm 49, with 250 Blacksmithing, and can't pick a specialization. The heck?
You need to go to SW and talk to Hank the Hammer near the forge to do the mithril order quests first before you can pick a specilization.