in your browser.
A social 25man, is it realistic?
Return to board index
I'm currently the guild master of a modest 10 man raiding guild called Disbanded. We've been having some trouble to fill our raid roster lately, since we've had about 4 ppl quit raiding at the same time, and now, weeks and weeks later, we still haven't managed to fill those slots, and it's starting to REALLY hurt our progression, and in tandem with that, our reputation as a raiding guild.
Now, me and my officers have been actively looking for people for over a month, but noone really seems interested in just another casual 10 man raiding guild. So I was wondering...
WHAT IF we transfered to 25man? I know, this would mean recruiting alot of people up front, but I, for one, really, really like the epic feeling of a 25man raid, and I know alot of other people feel the same way. Unfortunately, lately the only real 25man guilds have been hardcore and top end raiding guilds. Would a social, casual raiding guild that takes it easy on progression (let's say at least half heroic cleared by the end of the patch) appeal to people? I would really like your opinions on this subject, because I think it might just be a thing people are looking to find.
Imagine a recruitement message like:
<Disbanded>, THE social 25 man raiding guild is looking for more skilled members of any class our spec to get to raid those epic, big-battle 25 man raids! Do you feel your 10man just doesn't submerge you into the large fights enough? Always enjoyed the big social atmosphere of a 25man guild? Want to go 25 man, but no time for 3+ days a week of raiding? Look no further, Disbanded is here for you!
What would you feel about this?
Thanks in advance,
P.S.: if you happen to be on Auchindoun-EU and looking for a social/casual guild... Gimme a shout :p
I personally wouldn't be interested specifically in a 25-man guild over a 10-man, but that doesn't mean that there isn't a market for it. I think there are probably other people who miss the 25-man feel and would like to have that again.
On the other hand, if you're having trouble filling 4 more slots, do you think you're be successful at trying to fill 19 more? Also, I don't know if people who want to have the additional challenge of a 25-man group will be looking for a casual raid experience- they might be, but I'm not sure.
I'd recommend posting something on the official forums for your realm, and seeing if this is something that generates a lot of interest.
Yeah my thought process about the recruiting:
10man, casual, low progressed:
One of many, loads of other (and possibly better) options
Near as makes no difference unique
So the people looking for it may actually be more drawn to join it, instead of just the 'one-of-many' 10mans.
"Social" is a very vague definition and the pedestal on which of any number of unrealistic hopes regarding player/people behaviour has been placed over the years. Might want to be a bit more specific than that before rushing off to size up, just saying.
Yeah, like Elhonna said, if you're having problems finding 4 more for 10m, how are you gonna find 19 more for 25m? From experience, the 25m market is much smaller than 10m since it's a lot harder to deal with 25 different people's schedule and finding the right balance amongst the group.
Many of the 25m groups that are together today have been together through numerous expansions and have committed players to that set group.
OP, It isn't a simple matter of flipping a switch or suddenly deciding to be a 25 man raid guild.
You would need to quickly recruit 30+ people available to raid including your current group just to have a chance of getting 25 people on and ready for your schedule.
(Which is nigh on impossible)
The top guilds do it because they have a steady pool of raiders in their multiple groups, and pretty much every 25 man guild will have started with several 10 man teams and merged them into a 25 man once that was sustainable.
I suggest you check this site out, this will help you greatly.
I'm well aware of the challenges converting to a 25man would bring, I was just wondering if there would be a market for it. Seems as though it's pretty 'meh' overall though, appearantly not everyone misses 25mans as much as I do D:
Also, entropy, I know openraid, but how can it help me in my guild-stuff?
You might use Open Raid to look for those 4 people you can't find on your server for your current raid team, and if you find that they mesh with the group really well, the might even be willing to transfer to join your guild.
Of course there is a market for it! There is a market for everything. Casual 10s casual 25s, hardcore 10s , hardcore 25s (maybe slightly less hardcore 25s since the loot from from 10s was changed to be exactly the same as 25s). Ive been in the same 40man-25man casual raiding guild for almost 7 years now. We have our staffing issues, most casual groups do, we can't/don't prioritize raiding so sometimes we are short. But we still have fun and end up taking down the final tier before the xpac is over. It takes a while with a large group due to high gear diffusion, but its better than raiding with a bunch of ego-maniacal jack-holes. Keep at it! Spread the word. Ask around. Friends of Friends of Friends.
Also, entropy, I know openraid, but how can it help me in my guild-stuff?
It gives you a solid platform of raiders to ease the step up to 25 mans, and people are more likely to show up to raids that actually happen.
The people who use OpenRaid are your target demographic, frustrated players who want to raid but don't have that option to do so on their own servers.
I would think it more likely to create initially a cross realm raiding group, and with a stable base and a social base people can and do transfer servers to achieve their goals.
I'd love to see more 25 man raids across different guilds and I think there is certainly a market for it, but you need an end product to advertise. Most WoW players want something out of their time otherwise they'd be better off just sticking to LFR.
@Dork- but don't you think there's a difference between having a guild that survived the major shift from 40 to 25 to 10 man raiding, because they had started raiding together (and were already friends most likely) when you needed groups of those sizes for the various raids, and starting a brand new guild now, and trying to become a 25-man group?
Since you are social, I think trying to get 25 people together at the same time to raid might be a problem. You got busy schedules, excuses, computer problems, work and whatever else to deal with. I guess if you had a huge number of players in the guild playing on raid nights you could then fill the ranks.
Why not stay 10 man and go to trade to fill in those missing spots you need? Maybe sooner or later one or two of those who start to do regular runs with you guys might want to swap to your guild? If not and you can only get 5 from your guild at least you are getting in there on a regular basis.
Just a side note, do cross-realm raids even work with the current tier? (for the openraid thingy)
I totally agree. It's a much more difficult boss to slay... But it is still possible. We have always had the same core group of about 10 people since back in the day. Which makes it (admittedly) a lot easier. But I still think that putting a 25m casual group together is possible. It's just difficult. It takes a lot of word-of-mouth and a lot of recruiting and a lot trial and error. I think realm x-fers were a total bonus to a guild like mine. We were able to get our RL friends who played on other servers to come and raid with us. Has Merberan tried to go that route? We all know people that play right?
Just a side note, do cross-realm raids even work with the current tier? (for the open raid thingy)
Oh yeah- I forgot about that. It does not work for the current tier. However, you might still meet people doing old content that way. And maybe get some mounts and achievements knocked out in the meantime.
You are not logged in. Please
to post a reply or
if you don't already have an account.
Other ZAM Sites
Final Fantasy XI
© 2017 ZAM Network LLC