Post by Wombat62
Opinions on which of the two trinkets listed in title is the better one to go with Darkmoon trinket.
this is me http://us.battle.net/wow/en/character/Nagrand/Sulakin/advanced
I know I have some reforging to do as well but dont want to do it till i decide on the trinket
Post by Zakkhar
But based on stats, I'd go with Terror; agi/crit>mast/agi.
Worst comparison ever. You dont count reforging, amounts of average stats etc.
Terror procs on normal attacks but specific type of your own attack (direct hit), which means all your pet attacks including kill command and all your dot attacks wont be able to proc it.
Bottle is similar, although i managed to proc it from mining.
Now for proc chances/ICD (internal cds)/duration
Bottle 15% 45s 20s
Terror: 15% 105s 20s
If the proc occurs right afer icd that gives 44% uptime for bottle and 19% uptime for Terror.
2866 AGI with 44% uptime gives on average 1261 AGI
6121 crit with 19% uptime gives on average 1163 crit
So bottle is 382 crit (reforged from mastery) 574 mastery & 1261 agi from proc
Terror is 1041 AGI and 1163 crit from proc
Thats basically (on paper) Bottle: 574 mastery + 220 AGI vs Terror: 781 crit
I'd say bottle wins (on paper). In practice the uptimes will differ a lot from ideal uptime, which may make them much closer. And the actual benefit will depend greatly on spec, encounter and playstyle. But they are close.